The Library

4 At-Home Tasting Exercises to Find the Wines You Prefer

By Rapha Ventresca

· Tasting & Palate · 6 min read

4 At-Home Tasting Exercises to Find the Wines You Prefer

I spent my first two years in wine thinking I was broken. Someone would describe a wine as forest floor and black tea, and I’d taste wet grapes. I read tasting notes like a language I would never speak. Everyone else seemed to get it, and I kept asking myself why I didn’t.

Most wine education starts with information: grapes, regions, vintages, the “correct” tasting note. The assumption is that once you’ve read enough, you’ll taste it. Perception comes first. You build it by tasting two wines side by side and paying attention to what changes.

Below are four exercises. Do one every other day for a week. Each needs two bottles or fewer and a pen. The first also needs a friend to pour.

Exercise 1: Hide the labels on two Chardonnays

Two years into my sommelier career, I tasted my first $200 Burgundy, in a dim wine bar in New York. It smelled of wet forest floor and crushed cherries, and the body was lighter than I’d expected. I kept waiting for the awe everyone had promised. What I felt was self-conscious, as if I were missing something. I knew the price before the first sip, and I expected to taste $200.

Three things shape what you taste before the wine reaches your tongue.

  • Context. The room, the glass, the food, and above all the price. You will taste the same wine differently when you believe it cost $200 than when you believe it cost $15.
  • Expectation. If someone tells you to look for butter and vanilla, you will find butter and vanilla.
  • Attention. Most of the time a glass sits in your hand while you talk. Tasting means stopping to notice what happens in your mouth.

Hiding the labels removes the price and the label, the two biggest sources of bias in a tasting.

  • Buy two California Chardonnays at different prices. Bogle at about $12 and Rombauer at about $40 make a good pair.
  • Have someone pour each into identical glasses while you’re out of the room. Ask them to mark the base of each glass with tape so you can match it to a bottle later.
  • Taste both. Write down which you prefer and why, in your own words. Leave out any phrase you’ve read on a back label.
  • Reveal the labels, then taste both again with the labels showing.

Some people prefer the $12 bottle, some can’t tell the two apart, and some prefer the $40 bottle by a wide margin. If your preference changes on the second taste, the only new information you had was the price.

The question to sit with for a day: what changed once you knew which was which?

Exercise 2: Find acidity with two whites

Flavor descriptions shift when someone suggests them, as the butter-and-vanilla example shows. Structure is the physical sensation in your mouth, and you can train yourself to notice it. It has three parts.

  • Acidity makes your mouth water. High acid feels bright and makes you want another sip. Low acid feels soft and round. Think of a lemon next to a ripe banana.
  • Tannin, in red wine, dries your gums and tongue. It’s a texture you feel, like black tea steeped too long.
  • Body is weight. A light-bodied wine feels like skim milk. A full-bodied wine feels like whole milk or cream.

Pour a high-acid white next to a lower-acid one: Kim Crawford Sauvignon Blanc from New Zealand (about $17) beside Yalumba Y Series Viognier (about $13). The Rombauer from the first exercise also works as the softer wine. Ask yourself:

  • Which one makes you salivate more?
  • Which feels lighter, and which feels softer?
  • Which do you want to sip again?

The Sauvignon Blanc should make your mouth water more. That watering is acidity.

Exercise 3: Find tannin with two reds

In my first year as a sommelier I memorized tasting notes. I could recite “blackberry, cedar, and a hint of graphite” for hundreds of wines, and in front of a mystery glass I was lost. At a blind tasting in 2015, my mentor poured two reds side by side and asked one question: which one dries your mouth more? I could feel the answer right away. In one, my gums dried and tightened. The other felt smooth. I learned more about red wine from answering that question than from all the notes I’d memorized.

Pour a Pinot Noir next to a Cabernet Sauvignon. Willamette Valley Vineyards Whole Cluster Pinot Noir from Oregon (about $22) and Josh Cellars Cabernet (about $15) make a clear pair. Take a sip of each, hold it for a few seconds, and pay attention to your gums. Which one dries them more? That drying grip is tannin, and the Cabernet will have more of it.

Then finish this sentence: I tend to prefer wines that feel ______.

A few starting points:

  • bright and light
  • firm and drying
  • crisp and lean, with little fruit sweetness
  • rich and round

Say it to the person behind the counter at a wine shop: “bright, light, not much tannin.” A good clerk can pull three bottles from that sentence.

For more on structure, with bottle suggestions for each part, read Understanding Structure in Simple Terms.

Exercise 4: Revisit a wine you loved

I was at a dinner with twelve wine professionals when someone poured a 2005 cult Napa Cabernet, one of the small-production Napa Valley wines sold mostly through mailing lists for hundreds of dollars a bottle, with years of critical praise behind it. People around the table murmured, and a few started trading tasting notes. I took a sip, waited for the awe, and felt nothing. By every standard I’d been trained to use, the wine was flawless, and I didn’t care for it. I almost said something complimentary anyway.

The last skill is saying what you value, which is separate from recognizing quality. You can taste a famous wine, understand why people admire it, and decide you’d rather drink something else. That is a complete and useful answer.

Pour a wine you remember loving. Take a few minutes with it and ask:

  • What drew me to it: the acidity, the texture, the aroma, something else?
  • Is that still there tonight, or was part of it the occasion?
  • What does liking it say about what I want from a bottle?

Write the answer as one sentence that starts with I value, such as “I value whites with enough acidity to make my mouth water” or “I value reds with some drying grip.”

From there, taste across grapes, regions, and prices. Notice which bottles you go back to for a second glass. Buy more from that grape, region, or producer until you can explain why you like them.

Where to go next

By the end of the week you should have two sentences written down: how you like a wine to feel, and what you value in one. Read them out the next time you’re in a wine shop or handed a restaurant list. They describe your taste in your own words.

The Polished Palate library groups past issues by what you’re after: sharpening your palate, learning a region, buying better, pairing with food. Start wherever you’re curious.

Browse the library

If you run any of these, leave a comment with the result that surprised you. I read every one.

Get the next issue.

The Polished Palate lands every Saturday, free. Your welcome email starts you on four at-home tasting exercises.